Howard County’s pizza scene is thriving, even after the heartbreaking closure of Bennie’s earlier this year—a true loss for local pie lovers. But fear not, fellow crust connoisseurs: we've scoured the area to find the best slices still standing. Here’s your updated guide to the top pizza joints in HoCo, plus a bonus pick just outside the county that's worth the drive.
🍕 Top Pizza Spots in Howard County
1. Pupatella – Columbia
Style: Authentic Neapolitan, VPN-certified
Address: 9160 MD-108, Columbia, MD 21045
Phone: (443) 542-0098
Website: pupatella.com
Average Cost: $13–$18
Pupatella brings Naples to Columbia with its wood-fired, thin-crust pizzas. The Margherita is a must-try, boasting fresh mozzarella and basil on a perfectly charred crust.
2. Grotto Pizza – Columbia
Style: Delaware-style pan pizza
Address: 7075 Minstrel Way, Columbia, MD 21046
Phone: (443) 583-8200
Website: grottopizza.com
Average Cost: $15–$22
Known for its signature swirl of sweet tomato sauce atop a cheesy base, Grotto offers a unique twist on traditional pizza.The Mama Grotto is a fan favorite.
3. HomeSlyce – Columbia
Style: Creative, customizable pizzas
Address: 9400 Snowden River Pkwy #127, Columbia, MD 21045
Phone: (443) 491-4000
Website: homeslyce.com
Average Cost: $12–$20
HomeSlyce offers a modern take on pizza with its signature "Slyce" pies, allowing for endless topping combinations.Their cozy atmosphere makes it a great spot for gatherings.
4. Lucero's Pizza – Laurel
Style: Handcrafted, family-style pizzas
Address: 11200 Scaggsville Rd, Laurel, MD 20723
Phone: (301) 604-7744
Website: lucerospizza.com
Average Cost: $10–$18
A hidden gem, Lucero's offers hearty pizzas with generous toppings. Their Chicken Pesto pizza is a standout, combining savory flavors with a delightful crust.
5. Anthony's NY Pizza & Pasta House – Clarksville
Style: Classic New York-style pizza
Address: 5805 Clarksville Square Dr, Clarksville, MD 21029
Phone: (443) 535-9777
Website: anthonyspizzaandpastahouse.com
Average Cost: $14–$20
Anthony's delivers authentic New York-style slices with a perfect balance of crispy crust and gooey cheese. Their Margherita pizza is a simple yet satisfying choice.
6. Trattoria E Pizzeria Da Enrico – Columbia
Style: Traditional Italian pizzas
Address: 8630 Guilford Rd C70, Columbia, MD 21046
Phone: (410) 381-1255
Website: trattoriaenrico.com
Average Cost: $12–$18
This family-run spot offers a cozy atmosphere and classic Italian pizzas. Their Sicilian-style pies are thick, fluffy, and packed with flavor.
⭐ Bonus Pick: Andy's Pizza – Bethesda
Style: Award-winning New York-style pizza
Address: 4600 East-West Hwy, Bethesda, MD 20814
Phone: (240) 204-6883
Website: eatandyspizza.com
Average Cost: $25–$35
While not in Howard County, Andy's Pizza is worth the trip. Their Pepperoni Special, featuring hot honey and burrata, has garnered national acclaim. It's a must-try for any pizza enthusiast.
Whether you're a fan of thin-crust Neapolitan, hearty Sicilian, or creative modern pizzas, Howard County has a spot to satisfy your cravings. While we mourn the loss of Bennie's, these establishments ensure the local pizza scene remains vibrant and delicious.
